Increase in private HIEs raises concerns about compatibility

By Diana Manos
04:21 PM

Public health information exchanges (HIEs) have expressed concerns about compatibility and sustainability as the number of private HIEs continues to rise, according to eHealth Initiative's 12th Annual HIE Survey.

The survey of 161 HIEs nationwide indicates that if public and private HIEs are operating on different systems within a state or region, it will become increasingly difficult to exchange and leverage useful data to improve the quality and coordination of care in the United States, researchers said.

[See also: HIE as a verb: ONC wants to move quickly on data exchange.]

According to eHealth Initiative (eHI), there should be a level playing field between public and private HIEs.

"If these exchanges are not able to effectively operate in conjunction with one another, we may be heading to a point where we can no longer share data," eHI researchers said. "As a result, the intention of HIEs will be defeated."

"The primary purpose of HIEs is to provide increased access to data that allows providers to deliver safer, quicker and more cost-effective care for their patients," said Jennifer Covich Bordenick, chief executive officer of eHI. "If competing public and private HIEs are using different operating systems and technology platforms, data cannot be adequately shared."

Survey results indicate that more research is needed to determine whether or not growing competition between public and privates HIEs is a direct result of the guidelines and restrictions placed on the use of federal or state funds. Such restrictions may be contributing to the increasing number of private exchanges.

[See also: HIE as platform for innovation.]

The report also indicates that HIEs that have a diverse revenue base have been found over time to increase their chances of sustainability more than those that depend entirely on federal funds to operate.

The survey results can be found here.