Healthcare IT NewsHealthcare IT News
  • Home
  • Sections
    • Industry News
    • Hospitals & IDNs
    • Physician Practices & Ambulatory Care
    • Payers
    • Vendors
    • International
  • Issues
    • February 2010
    • January 2010
    • December 2009
    • November 2009
    • October 2009
    • Sept. 2009
  • Resource Central
    • All Resources
    • Research
    • White Papers
    • Web Seminars
    • Videos
    • Podcasts
  • Blog
  • Events
  • Jobs
  • About
  • Subscribe
  • Advertise
  • Newsletters
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Solutions Series
Select Your Homepage
Search eConnect
Login | Register
Home » News » Industry News

E-mail to a FriendPrint
Social Bookmarking
  • Delicious Delicious
  • Digg Digg
  • StumbleUpon StumbleUpon
  • Reddit Reddit
  • Newsvine Newsvine
  • Furl Furl
  • Facebook Facebook
  • Google Google
  • Yahoo Yahoo
Blumenthal says HITECH faces challenges

Blumenthal says HITECH faces challenges

April 10, 2009 | Molly Merrill, Associate Editor

Suggested Content

  • Public comments will shape final meaningful use rule
  • HIT Policy Committee meets today
  • Providers skeptical of meaningful use reimbursement process
  • ONC policy committee approves recommendations on meaningful use
  • New health IT policy, standards panels start work
  • Readers have a thing or two to say about CCHIT
  • Glaser poised to advise new healthcare IT chief Blumenthal
  • Harvard's teaching hospital to connect four physician offices
  • Vendor Notebook - e-MDs launches community HIE
  • Survey: physicians slow to adopt EHRs

BOSTON – David Blumenthal, MD, the newly appointed National Coordinator for Health Information Technology, sees "major hurdles" for the HITECH Act, according to a New England Journal of Medicine article.

The HITECH Act, the portion of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (ARRA) that deals with healthcare information technology, is set to help doctors adopt HIT, specifically electronic health records.

The law uses a "carrot and stick approach" where eligible doctors will receive incentive payments for the first five years for demonstrating "a meaningful use" of EHR technology and demonstrated performance during the reporting period for each payment year. If an eligible professional does not demonstrate meaningful use by 2015, his/her reimbursement payments under Medicare will begin to be reduced. No incentive payment will be made after 2016.

Blumethal says spurring the adoption of EHRs and other HIT will probably require more than financial carrots and sticks.

"Proponents of HIT expansion face substantial problems," he said. "Few U.S. doctors or hospitals – perhaps 17 percent and 10 percent, respectively – have even basic EHRs, and there are significant barriers to their adoption and use: their substantial cost, the perceived lack of financial return from investing in them, the technical and logistic challenges involved in installing, maintaining and updating them, and consumers' and physicians' concerns about the privacy and security of electronic health information."

Blumenthal said these problems will create a "substantial down payment on the financial and human resources needed to wire the U.S. healthcare system."

"First, the DHHS and ONCHIT are operating on a very tight schedule. The infrastructure to support HIT adoption should be in place well before 2011 if physicians and hospitals are to be prepared to benefit from the most generous Medicare and Medicaid bonuses," he said. 

Blumenthal said this will be a challenge.

John Halamka, MD, CIO of Harvard Medical School and the CareGroup Health System, is adamant that implementation should start now. Unless the health information exchange is up and running and providing meaningful use, the money won't be, he told attendees at the 2009 Healthcare Information Management Systems Society's conference this past week in Chicago.

Blumenthal said much will depend on how "certified EHR" and "meaningful use" are defined.

The "meaningful use" of healthcare IT will be determined by HHS Secretary-nominee Kathleen Sebelius. If she is confirmed by the Senate, she will also oversee standards development and select clinical quality measures used to determine providers' worthiness for receiving healthcare IT incentives under the new law.

"Realizing the full potential of HIT depends in no small measure on changing the healthcare system's overall payment incentives so that providers benefit from improving the quality and efficiency of the services they provide. Only then will they be motivated to take full advantage of the power of EHRs," said Blumenthal.
 

Related Topics:
  • Boston
  • David Blumenthal
  • information technology
  • Medicare
  • New England
  • stimulus

Reader Comments (2)Login to Post a Comment

reefdiver says:

April 20, 2009 | 9:55AM GMT

CCHIT May be HITECH's Biggest Challenge

Drjj speaks for many busy, practicing physicians and practices out there.

Most surveys for the past five years, which have attempted to get at the root of why EMR adoption has been so low and de-install rate so high, show that the two top reasons have been cost and difficulty to use. Will the funding now being provided by the Stimulus Bill--up to $44,000 per physicians under Medicare or even $63,000 under Medicaid--change that and quickly enable ALL practices to adopt and use EMR? How can it...it only addresses HALF the problem?

My guess...and much of the conventional wisdom in the industry...is that Stimulus Bill funding will not be successful under the current circumstances. It may increase the adoption rate initially, as the enthusiasm and momentum for "change" drive things, and under the premise of EVENTUAL reimbursement (over five years). But it absolutely WILL NOT change the success rate of implementations. And likely, billions of Stimulus money will be wasted. WHY? One simple reason. CCHIT-driven certification.

CCHIT-certified systems are basically "Government EMR". The continually expanding 480+ criteria to be "certified" continue to ignore "usability" as a criteria for earning the credential. Despite that government-funded groups' good intentions and hard work, results are still disappointing and adoption rate is low. With a 50+% failure rate on installations even with CCHIT credentialling up to now, why should that improve by government dollars partially reimbursing practices for the same systems? In fact, if you accept the notion that the most tech-savvy physicians are those most likely to have already implemented---or attempted to---then the "other 80+%" of physicians will be even less-likely to succeed. EMR systems have no "usablility" measures for physicians to compare. Stimulus funding is betting the farm---over $36 billion (less PROJECTED savings of $17 Billion---where does that come from? What if it doesn't?)--that this will work. Can we afford to squander billions of dollars on this "bet"?

While there are several landmark studies from highly reputable institutions and firms that conclude that CCHIT-based EMR implementation has produced NO broad-market results such as documented cost savings, reduction in medical errors or improved care results, there is not ONE landmark study that concludes to the contrary. Can anyone produce such a study? Can we continue on a path of providing billions for these systems where the benefits are still anecdotal? And where the physicians and practices have to pay the cost and the insurance companies receive the benefit?

Why not take a million or two dollars and have a truly independent, reputable institution find out some answers in this area...before we spend $36 billion like it is the answer to the problem?

Lets hope Ms. Sebelius, upon her deserved approval as White House Health Reform Czar, and Mr. Blumenthal upon his ascension to ONC look a lot harder at this. Committees for CCHIT and even the nascent group being put forward for HITSP seem to ignore the inclusion of high-performance, busy, practicing physicians in deciding for that group what it needs...plus defining for those who will use it, what "meaningful use" is. Those are the criteria that will govern "reimbursement"...and are not very well spelled out yet. But all seem to think that the CCHIT criteria will be the starting point. Why is no one looking at the tremendous success and high adoption rate of Hybrid EMR, for example, as an alternative guidepost?

CCHIT guidelines...in driving "Government EMR" direction... may be the biggest barrier of them all in achieving the goals the HITECH Act set out to accomplish.

Login to Post a Comment

drjj says:

April 17, 2009 | 9:53AM GMT

Health IT

While the widespread implementation of EHR's is a laudable goal, it doesn't appear that the practical realities of what this means for practicing phyicians has received adequate attention.

For them, this is an expensive and disruptive proposition. When businesses make this commitment, they know that any resultant financiial benefit will accrue to their bottom line. When private practicing physicians make these investments in time and money, they do stand to improve their quality (which most believe is high anyway), but the financial benefits accrue mainly to the insurance companies.

I wonder how many large corporations, several of whose leadership I heard clamoring for more widespread acceptance of EHR's by physicians @recent World Health Care Conference in Washington, would spend for IT in this model.

And all this at a time when CMS seems to think it's a good idea to continue either freezing or reducing physician Medicare payments every year!

I commend the current administration for making some funds available for this purpose; but if the barriers are too high and the requirements too stringent along with inadequate reimbursement, it's unlikely we'll get to the 5-year time frame goal which has been set to accomplish widespread EHR adoption.

Login to Post a Comment

receive news by email

Most Popular

Latest Headlines
Most Popular
  • Five healthcare IT decisions to avoid
  • Blumenthal: EHRs will become 'an absolute requisite' for docs
  • Video program puts docs at bedside 24/7 at MassGeneral
  • FCC to promote mobile health apps
  • Spheris bankruptcy could spark bidding war, with MedQuist in the lead
  • Sankaran maps government's promotion of healthcare IT
  • North Carolina group offers help with ARRA
  • New Hampshire hospital pulls its data together
  • KLAS questions vendor claims on HIEs
  • Terso expands to Germany

Resource Central

  • Web Seminars
    On-Demand--Integrated, Real-time Decision Making – A Prescription for Improving Patient Outcomes and Your Bottom Line
  • White Papers
    St. Francis Care Uses Leading Edge Technology to Deliver First Class Healthcare Services
  • White Papers
    Solving Desktop Challenges in Healthcare with ScriptLogic's Desktop Authority
  • Research
    Business Trends - Healthcare Technology
  • Web Seminars
    On-Demand--Part II-The Crystal Clear Healthcare Provider: How Cleveland Clinic Delivers Transparency to Stakeholders with Business Intelligence
More Resources
Syndicate content

HEALTHCARE IT JOB SPOT

  • Software Engineer - GE Healthcare - Boston, MA
  • Lead Software Engineer - GE Healthcare - Boston, MA
  • Conversion Analyst - GE Healthcare - WA
  • Show Site Director - GE Healthcare - North Carolina
  • Health Information Manager - Center for Spinal Surgery - Nashville, TN
more jobs

  • Destination HIMSS

    Going to HIMSS this year? Then you can't afford to miss our Destination HIMSS site and newsletter. 

  • EHRWatch.com

    EHRWatch.com offers news, commentary and community participation on the developments in electronic health records.

  • Priming the Pump

    Priming the Pump provides practical news on the stimulus package and the incentives that it offers to healthcare providers.

  • Facebook

    Join Healthcare IT News on Facebook to connect with other readers!

  • NHINWatch

    Visit NHINWatch.com for coverage of the Nationwide Health Information Network.

  • Mobile Health Watch

    Stay up to date on the latest mobility news at Mobile Health Watch.

  • MedTech Publishing

    Visit our company Web page to learn more about MedTech Publishing.

  • LinkedIn

    Join our LinkedIn group to connect with other readers. Click here to join the group.

     

  • Healthcare IT Job Spot

    Check out the latest open positions at Healthcare IT Job Spot.

Marketplace

  • Home
  • Issues
  • Resource Central
  • Blog
  • Events
  • Subscribe
  • Advertise
  • About Us
  • Site Map
  • Privacy Policy
Healthcare IT News is a publication of MedTech Publishing Company LLC.
For more information about MedTech Publishing Company and its publications, please visit medtechpublishing.com.
©2009 MedTech Publishing
Powered by Phase2 Technology.